Reply to Sairen-bo

I have carefully noted the contents of your letter. I have also received safely the various articles that came from the capital. When I was living in Kamakura, such articles were a daily sight, but since having been exiled to this island, I have yet to encounter them. To come upon articles such as these on this tiny faraway island is truly a most welcome event.

In your letter you mention that you became a disciple of mine and pledged to follow me at the beginning of the second month, and that from now on, though you may not measure up to other persons, you would be most pleased and honored if I would continue to count you among my disciples.

The sutra says: "They were constantly reborn with their teachers in various Buddha lands. And it also says: "If one stays close to the teachers of the Law, he will speedily gain the bodhisattva way. By following and learning from these teachers, he will see Buddhas as numerous as Ganges sands."

A commentary states: "Originally one followed this Buddha and for the first time conceived the desire to seek the way. And by following this Buddha again, one will reach the stage where there is no retrogression." Another commentary states: "In the beginning one followed this Buddha or bodhisattva and formed a bond with him, and so it will be through this Buddha or bodhisattva that one will realize one’s goal."

When I consider these passages of the sutra and the commentaries, I wonder if you and I have not been pledged to each other as teacher and disciple from countless kalpas in the past. The fact that you and I have been born in this defiled age of the Latter Day of the Law, in the country of Japan in the southern continent of Jambudvipa, that with the utmost reverence we chant with our mouths Nam-myoho-renge-kyo, the ultimate reason for which all Buddhas appear in the world, that we have faith in it in our hearts, embrace it with our bodies and delight in it with our hands--all of this has come about, has it not, entirely as a result of some old bond of karma from the past?

When I look at the situation in Japan, I find that the Devil of the Sixth Heaven has entered into the bodies of people of wisdom, transforming correct teachers into heretical teachers, and good teachers into bad teachers. This is what the sutra means when it says, "Evil demons will take possession of others."

Although I, Nichiren, am not a man of wisdom, the Devil of the Sixth Heaven has attempted to take possession of my body. But I have for some time been taking such great care that he now no longer comes near me. Therefore, because the power of the heavenly devil is ineffectual against me, he instead possesses the ruler and his high officials, or stupid priests such as Ryokan, and causes them to hate me.

Be that as it may, one should understand that at present, when it comes to teachers, there is a difference between correct teachers and heretical teachers, between good teachers and bad teachers. One should shun those who are heretical or evil, and associate with those who are correct and good. Even if their virtue is known throughout the four seas and their wisdom is as bright as the sun and moon, one should recognize that teachers who slander the Lotus Sutra are evil teachers and heretical teachers, and refrain from drawing near them. A certain sutra warns us on this point: "If there are slanderers of the Law, one should not dwell with them. If one draws near them and dwells with them, one will be bound for the Avichi hell."

No matter how honest and upright you may be, or how you may strive to be known as a worthy person in the secular or the religious world, if you associate with evil persons, then as a natural result you will find that, in two or three instances out of ten, you are following their teachings, and in the end you, too, will become an evil person. Thus the commentary says: "Though one may not be evil to begin with, if he associates with and is friendly with evil persons, he himself is bound in time to become an evil person, and his evil reputation will spread throughout the world."

In the end, what we mean by heretical and evil teachers are those priests in the world today who slander the Lotus Sutra. The Nirvana Sutra says: "Bodhisattvas, have no fear of mad elephants. What you should fear are evil friends! Even if you are killed by a mad elephant, you will not fall into the three evil paths. But if you are killed by an evil friend, you are certain to fall into them." And the Lotus Sutra says: "In that evil age there will be monks with perverse wisdom and hearts that are fawning and crooked..."

As I have pointed out so many times in the past, when teachers such as Shan-wu-wei, Chin-kang-chih, Bodhidharma, Huik-k’o, Shan-tao, Honen, Kobo of To-ji, Chisho of Onjo-ji, Jikaku of Mount Hiei or Ryokan of Kanto read the golden words, "I ... honestly discarding expedient means, [will preach only the unsurpassed way,]" they take them to mean, "honestly discarding the true teachings, I will preach only the expedient teachings." When they read the passage that says, "Among the sutras, it [the Lotus Sutra] holds the highest place," they take it to mean, "Among the sutras, it holds the lowest place." And when they read, "[Among those sutras] the Lotus is the foremost," they take it to mean, "The Lotus holds second place," or "holds third place." That is why I describe these various priests as heretical and evil teachers.

Those that I call correct and good teachers are persons who take Shakyamuni Buddha’s golden words to mean just what they say, namely, that the other sutras represent expedient means and the Lotus Sutra represents the truth.

In this connection, you should consult the Nyuhokkai chapter, the seventy-seventh volume of the Kegon Sutra. And the Lotus Sutra states: "A good friend is the great cause and condition by which one is guided and led, and that enables one to see the Buddha and to conceive the desire for supreme perfect enlightenment."

As the Buddha tells us, we should regard as correct teachers and good teachers those who honestly discard the doctrines of the four flavors and three teachings, the Hinayana and provisional Mahayana sutras that were expounded as expedient means, as well as the Nembutsu, Shingon, Zen and Ritsu sects and the sutras upon which they rely, and expound Myoho-renge-kyo, "the one great reason for which the Buddhas appear in the world."

As for myself, I, Nichiren, having been born in Japan in the first five hundred years of the Latter Day of the Law, have encountered the three powerful enemies and met with various types of calamity and trouble, just as the Buddha predicted would happen. But, without any thought for my person or my life, I chant Nam-myoho-renge-kyo. I ask you to consider with the utmost care whether I deserve to be called a correct teacher or a heretical teacher.

Each of the proponents of the various sects mentioned above declares that he above all others has grasped the meaning of the Lotus Sutra and is practicing the Lotus Sutra. But none of them have been exiled to the province of Izu as I was in the Kocho era, or exiled to the island of Sado as I was in the Bun’ei era, or been led to the place of decapitation at Tatsunokuchi or faced the countless other difficulties that I have. If the sutra passages [that predict such difficulties] are true, then you should realize that I am the correct teacher, the good teacher, and that the scholars of the other sects are all heretical teachers and evil teachers.

In addition to these, there are a great many other passages in the sutras and treatises that make clear the distinction between these two types of teachers, the good and the bad. But I am sure you are already familiar with them, so I will not go into them here.

How wondrous, that in your letter you say that from now on you will reject the heretical teachers of our time and will rely entirely upon me as the correct teacher! When Shakyamuni Buddha, our original teacher, appeared in the world in order to expound the Lotus Sutra, like shadows and echoes the Buddhas and bodhisattvas of the other worlds came forth and assisted him in his efforts to spread the teachings. And now it seems that they have appeared here in Japan as envoys of Shakyamuni, Taho and the other Buddhas of the ten directions to help me in my efforts to spread the teachings!

The sutra says: "I will send persons conjured up by magic to other lands to gather together assemblies to listen to the Law. And I will also send [monks, nuns, laymen and laywomen conjured up by magic to listen to the preaching of the Law. These persons conjured up by magic will listen to the Law, believe and accept it,] and abide by it without violation." The "monks" who are spoken of in this passage refer to you. Therefore, when the sutra speaks of persons who "listen to the Law, believe and accept it, and abide by it without violation," clearly this is something that you yourself are living. How can there be any doubt of it?

Although the sutra speaks of those who are "constantly reborn with their teachers in various Buddha lands," there are persons like the three groups of voice-hearers who, after receiving the seeds of Buddhahood, reject the Mahayana, select the Hinayana and sink into the five paths or the six paths for a succession of rebirths, but when the time to achieve Buddhahood arrives, they are able to obtain emancipation, one after another. How gratifying, to think that you have now cast aside the heretical doctrines and heretical teachers of the Nembutsu, Shingon and other sects, and become a disciple of Nichiren!

In any case, like me, you should condemn the slander of the Law committed by the followers of the other sects and cause them to reject the heretical and embrace the correct. Then, when you arrive in the Land of Eternally Tranquil Light where the three types of Buddhas are seated, and appear before the Buddhas Shakyamuni and Taho, you will ask, "Were Nichiren and I bound by a promise to be teacher and disciple from the beginningless past, or were we not? Was I sent as an envoy of Shakyamuni Buddha to assist him in his efforts to spread the teachings?" And when the Buddhas reply, "Just so!" then you, too, will understand in your own mind why these things happened. Therefore you must by all means be diligent! You must be diligent!

As a matter of course, I began giving you instruction in the important doctrines around the second month. And as a result, on the eighth day of the fourth month, late at night in the Hour of the Tiger (around 4:00 A.M.), I performed for you the ceremony for ordination in the precept of the perfect teaching of the Mystic Law.

How could a person who has undergone this ordination fail to become a Buddha of perfect enlightenment in his present existence? And if in this life you have attained the level of perfect enlightenment, then in your next life, how could you have any reason to regress to the stage of near-perfect enlightenment and other lower stages of practice? In view of our promise from the beginningless past and the principle that one will be constantly reborn with one’s teacher, if I, Nichiren, attain Buddhahood in my present lifetime, then how could it be possible for you to become separated from me and fall into the evil realms of existence?

The prophecies of the Buddha recorded in the scripture, when viewed in the light of the Buddha’s true intentions, never contain the slightest falsehood with regard to either secular or religious matters. Now, in the Lotus Sutra it is stated: "After I have passed into extinction, one should accept and uphold this sutra. Such a person assuredly and without doubt will attain the Buddha way." And it also says, "This way one will quickly attain the unsurpassed Buddha way." If these passages of prophecy should be meaningless and if the prediction that we will attain Buddhahood should be a lie, then the tongues of all the Buddhas will break apart, the tower of Taho Buddha will crumble and fall, the place upon which the two Buddhas [Shakyamuni and Taho] are seated side by side will be changed into a bed of burning iron in the hell of incessant suffering, and the three lands of Transition, Actual Reward and Eternally Tranquil Light will be transformed into the three evil realms of hell, hungry spirits and animals. But how could such a thing be possible?

So day and night I ponder the important doctrines, and hour by hour, moment by moment, I savor the principle that allows us to attain Buddhahood. And because I pass the time in this fashion, though months and years go by, it does not seem long at all, and the hours that have elapsed do not seem like many. It is similar to the case described in the sutra, when the two Buddhas Shakyamuni and Taho, seated side by side in the Treasure Tower, nodded in approval over the wonderful principles of the Lotus Sutra and although fifty small kalpas had elapsed, because of the supernatural powers of the Buddha, it seemed to the great crowd assembled there like no more than half a day.

Among all the persons since the beginning of our present kalpa who have incurred the displeasure of their parents or their rulers and have been exiled to distant islands, there can be none who overflow with joy as we do. Therefore, wherever we dwell and practice the single vehicle, that place will be the capital of Eternally Tranquil Light. And, without having to advance a step, those who are our disciples and lay supporters can view Eagle Peak in India and day and night will go to and from the Land of Eternally Tranquil Light that has existed for all time. How inexpressibly joyful to think of it!

So delightful is the thought that I want now to make a promise to you. If you should be released quickly from exile and return to the capital, although the lord of Kamakura23 may continue to refuse pardon to Nichiren, I will call upon the heavenly deities, and when I have returned to Kamakura, I will write to you in Kyoto. And if I should be pardoned first and return to Kamakura, I will call upon the heavenly gods to make certain that you are able to return to your hometown, the ancient capital.